What the Ministry checks
AC4 appears on the Claims Error Report. The Ministry lists several conditions: the number is not six digits, it matches the billing practitioner's number, or a nurse practitioner or midwife referral is used for a service that does not accept that referral type. The returned code does not by itself identify which condition applies.
Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Error Report Rejection Conditions
Work from the referral record
Use these practical checks to locate the problem without replacing the referrer with someone else. A directory result should help confirm the person documented on the referral, rather than supply a convenient number.
- Open the referral or requisition associated with this encounter. Identify who actually requested the service and compare that person with the claim.
- Verify the referring provider's OHIP billing number against reliable practice information. Check for a missing digit, transposition, a different identifier pasted into the field, or the billing physician's own number.
- Review the fee code's referral requirements. Determine whether the actual referrer's provider type is eligible for that particular service; six digits alone do not establish eligibility.
- Correct a confirmed entry error and retain the supporting referral. If the documentation is incomplete, contact the referring office for clarification rather than guessing.
- If the original referral does not satisfy the selected service's requirements, have the physician review the documented service and applicable billing rules before changing the code.
Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Interface to Health Care Systems Technical Specifications · Ontario Ministry of Health — Physician payment · Ontario Ministry of Health — Error Report Rejection Conditions
Keep nearby referral errors distinct
AC4 is not an instruction to add any referring number. Read all returned messages and investigate the condition they describe. If the number matches the source document but the claim still rejects, seek clarification with the actual referral and rejected item available.
Referral requirements vary by service. The technical specifications include a fee-code relationships table, while the Schedule's payment rules determine what the clinical service must satisfy. Confirm both when the claim involves an unusual referral type.
Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Interface to Health Care Systems Technical Specifications · Ontario Ministry of Health — Physician payment
Check the corrected response
Keep the original rejection and the corrected submission reference together. After resubmission, review the next reports for any remaining errors. If a related claim already appears on the RA, reconcile it before creating another copy or use the inquiry process when its assessed details need correction.
Illustrative example
Synthetic example: the billing physician's number was copied
A clinic template places the treating physician's billing number in the referring field. The encounter has a genuine referral from a different provider, but the submitted claim returns AC4. The biller checks the referral, confirms the actual referrer's billing number and corrects the field. The team also repairs the template so future claims do not repeat the substitution.
Questions about this guide
Can I use a colleague's number if the referral is missing?
No. The claim should reflect the actual referral. Ask for the missing documentation or have the physician review the appropriate billing approach for the service provided.
Does an NP referral always cause AC4?
No. The issue can be whether the particular service accepts that referral type. Verify the fee-specific rules instead of replacing a genuine NP referral with a physician's number.
Official sources and scope
This is an independent explanation by OHIPay. Apply the Ministry rules and fee information in effect on the date the service was provided. Examples illustrate the workflow; they do not establish eligibility or guarantee payment.
- Ontario Ministry of Health — Error Report Rejection Conditions
Cover: December 2022; General error codes, printed pages 3–4. Checked October 12, 2026.
- Ontario Ministry of Health — Interface to Health Care Systems Technical Specifications
Version 6.2, April 1, 2023; section 4.10, Fee Schedule Code Relationships, printed pages 39–64.
- Ontario Ministry of Health — Physician payment
General Preamble overview, Medical records, and Non-emergency acute care hospital in-patient services; checked October 12, 2026.
- Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission
Updated April 22, 2026; Reports, Claims Error Report, Reconciliation and payment, and Inquiries.
Found a change or an error? Send a correction with the guide title and official reference.