Rejection codes

OHIP error A3E: check whether the service code existed on the visit date

A3E means OHIP does not recognize the billed service code for the submitted service date. Start with the complete fee code and its effective period; changing the amount alone does not resolve that question.

Read the complete rejection

A3E belongs to the Claims Error Report. Match the response to the rejected item and read every accompanying message before deciding what to change. An RA payment question requires a different review from a claim returned for correction.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission

Check the code against the encounter

Use these practical checks to identify whether a typing error, an old template or a mismatch between the recorded encounter and the selected code needs attention. A valid-looking code can still be inappropriate for a particular period.

  1. Compare the entire submitted code, including its suffix, with the encounter record and the intended service. Check an imported billing sheet or saved template as well as the visible claim.
  2. Confirm the actual service date from the clinical record. Correct a transcription error only when the record supports it; keep the true date if it falls outside a code's effective period.
  3. Find the applicable Schedule of Benefits and any relevant implementation bulletin. Verify when the code became available or ceased to apply.
  4. If a different code accurately represents the documented service and meets the applicable payment rules, correct the rejected item. If that remains uncertain, obtain billing clarification before sending another claim.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — OHIP Schedule of Benefits and fees · Ontario Ministry of Health — Bulletin 221203: Virtual Health Care in Ontario

Retired templates deserve special attention

Ontario's virtual-care transition provides a concrete historical example: the temporary K080–K083 and K092–K095 codes ended for services after November 30, 2022. The Ministry identified A3E as the outcome when those codes were used for later service dates. This illustrates why copying an old encounter can carry a code into the wrong period.

That example is not a current coding recommendation. Select the service supported by the actual encounter and the rules applicable to that date; do not choose a replacement solely because software accepts it.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Bulletin 221203: Virtual Health Care in Ontario

Close the correction loop

Retain the rejected claim's identifier, the reason for the correction and the replacement submission reference. Review the next returned reports to confirm the outcome. If the claim is already recorded on an RA, investigate the payment record and the appropriate inquiry route before creating another submission.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission

Illustrative example

Synthetic example: an old template survives a code change

A clinic copies a historic virtual-visit template into a later encounter. The actual visit date is correct, but the template still contains a discontinued temporary code. After an A3E response, the biller reviews the encounter with the physician, checks the applicable virtual-care requirements and corrects the code only if those requirements are met. The visit date stays unchanged.

Questions about this guide

Does A3E prove the care was uninsured?

No. It identifies a problem with the service-code/date combination submitted. Whether the documented care is insured under another code requires a separate review of the applicable rules.

Should I simply use today's fee schedule?

Start with the rules applicable to the actual service date. Today's list helps identify changes, but a later edition does not automatically determine how an earlier service should be billed.

Official sources and scope

This is an independent explanation by OHIPay. Apply the Ministry rules and fee information in effect on the date the service was provided. Examples illustrate the workflow; they do not establish eligibility or guarantee payment.

  1. Ontario Ministry of Health — Error Report Rejection Conditions

    Cover: December 2022; General error codes, printed pages 3–4. Checked October 12, 2026.

  2. Ontario Ministry of Health — OHIP Schedule of Benefits and fees

    Updated August 13, 2026; Schedule of Benefits for Physician Services and Physician Fee Schedule Master.

  3. Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission

    Updated April 22, 2026; Reports, Claims Error Report, Reconciliation and payment, and Inquiries.

  4. Ontario Ministry of Health — Bulletin 221203: Virtual Health Care in Ontario

    COVID-19 virtual care K-codes and Ontario Virtual Care Program sections; change effective December 1, 2022.

Found a change or an error? Send a correction with the guide title and official reference.

Related reading

Working in OHIPay

Bring the correction back to the claim.

OHIPay keeps the Ministry response beside the claim and provides a draft correction workflow for rejected claims. Review the changes before sending a replacement.

Then $20/month + HST per physician. No credit card to start. See pricing and what’s included.