Rejection codes

OHIP error A34: reconcile duplicate claims before sending again

A34 signals that OHIP has identified multiple duplicate claims. The useful next step is to find the earlier submission and its outcome, so a retry does not repeat a service already in the payment process.

Separate the rejected copy from the original

A34 is a Claims Error Report code. It is distinct from RA explanations such as 32 and 35, which concern services previously claimed. The report type matters: the rejected duplicate and a previously assessed claim can require different follow-up.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Error Report Rejection Conditions · Ontario Ministry of Health — Remittance Advice Explanatory Codes

Build a short submission history

Treat the following as a reconciliation checklist. It helps establish which record represents the service and whether an earlier submission was rejected, remains unresolved or appears on an RA.

  1. Match the patient, physician, actual service date, fee codes and quantities. Use claim or accounting references to connect the local record with Ministry responses.
  2. Check all relevant submission batches and returned reports, including uploads made by another authorized biller. A local status label alone may not tell you what happened to an earlier file.
  3. Locate the original claim's RA entry or error response. Distinguish a duplicate entry from two separately documented services that happen to share some billing fields.
  4. Record the finding before taking further action: accidental extra copy, genuine correction of a rejected original, or distinct service needing clarification. Keep both references so the history remains understandable.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission

Choose the action that fits the evidence

If the extra record is an accidental repeat of the same service, resolve that duplicate in the local workflow and follow the original claim's outcome. Do not turn the duplicate into a new service by changing its date, code or quantity.

For an original claim returned with a correctable error, repair that error and verify there is not already another correction awaiting a response. For a claim already on an RA, use the Ministry's inquiry process when its payment or details need review. A distinctly documented second service still needs to meet the applicable payment requirements; matching dates alone do not settle that question.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission · Ontario Ministry of Health — Physician payment

Prevent another uncertain retry

Assign one person to reconcile an unresolved submission and record each upload reference in the billing workflow. Before recreating a claim after a timeout or delayed report, check whether the previous transmission produced a response. This is an operational precaution, not a guarantee that a duplicate will always be detected before submission.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission

Illustrative example

Synthetic example: two billers act on the same visit

A covering biller uploads a claim while a second person recreates the same visit from a paper list. The second record returns A34. The team traces the first claim to an RA entry, closes the extra local record as a duplicate and investigates any payment question against the original. It does not send a third copy.

Questions about this guide

Does A34 tell me that the original was paid?

It identifies duplicate claims, but you still need the earlier claim's reports to establish its payment outcome. Do not mark it paid based solely on A34.

What if these were two real services?

Compare the separate encounter documentation and the relevant billing rules. If the distinction cannot be represented accurately or the earlier payment is disputed, seek clarification through the appropriate Ministry process.

Official sources and scope

This is an independent explanation by OHIPay. Apply the Ministry rules and fee information in effect on the date the service was provided. Examples illustrate the workflow; they do not establish eligibility or guarantee payment.

  1. Ontario Ministry of Health — Error Report Rejection Conditions

    Cover: December 2022; General error codes, printed pages 3–4. Checked October 12, 2026.

  2. Ontario Ministry of Health — Claims submission

    Updated April 22, 2026; Reports, Claims Error Report, Reconciliation and payment, and Inquiries.

  3. Ontario Ministry of Health — Remittance Advice Explanatory Codes

    April 2026 file; printed page 2, explanatory codes 32 and 35.

  4. Ontario Ministry of Health — Physician payment

    General Preamble overview, Medical records, and Non-emergency acute care hospital in-patient services; checked October 12, 2026.

Found a change or an error? Send a correction with the guide title and official reference.

Related reading

Working in OHIPay

Bring the correction back to the claim.

OHIPay keeps the Ministry response beside the claim and provides a draft correction workflow for rejected claims. Review the changes before sending a replacement.

Then $20/month + HST per physician. No credit card to start. See pricing and what’s included.